Follow us
Publications Commentary Research People Events News Resources and Videos About IFS
Home Publications An in-depth analysis of the returns to National Vocational Qualifications obtained at Level 2

An in-depth analysis of the returns to National Vocational Qualifications obtained at Level 2

Lorraine Dearden, Leslie McGranahan and Barbara Sianesi
External publication
Recent government policy has focused on helping low-skilled individuals obtain a Level 2 qualification. Previous work using the Labour Force Survey has however found that controlling for other qualifications achieved, individuals holding low-level National Vocational Qualifications (NVQs) have statistically significantly lower wage levels than otherwise similar individuals who lack NVQs, the estimates for NVQs at level 1 and 2 falling between 5 and 20 percent lower wages.

In this paper, we offer an in-dept investigation of NVQ qualifications, trying to shed some light as to why a seemingly beneficial certification of skill appears to hurt labour market prospects. We principally look at NVQs obtained at level 2 given that they are the most widely held of the NVQ qualifications, but will also touch on NVQs at level 1. While we focus on wages, we also investigate whether NVQs are a stepping-stone to higher levels of qualifications or serve to boost employment probabilities. Finally, we compare the returns to NVQ2s to the returns for other level 2 vocational qualifications.

More on this topic

Press release
Press release circulated for report on the health impacts of Sure Start (IFS R155)
Press release
The current system of funding undergraduate education means that costs to government are highest for subjects where graduates earn the least, and lowest for subjects where they earn the most. This is an unintended consequence of the English loan-based system, which costs taxpayers about £9 billion ...
Briefing note
This work estimates how government spending is distributed by subject studied and university attended, based on grants and unrepaid student loans (including both tuition and maintenance loans).
Journal article | Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics
Graduates from higher income families (with median income of around £77,000) have average earnings which are 20% higher than those from lower income families (with median income of around £26,000). Once we condition on institution and subject choices, this premium roughly halves, to around 10%.