Browse IFS
Publication types
Journal Articles
December 2003
Article
Ownership and Production Costs: Choosing between Public Production and Contracting-Out in the Case of Swedish Refuse Collection
Type: Journal Articles
Authors: Henry Ohlsson
ISSN: Print: 0143-5671 Online: 1475-5890
Volume, issue, pages: Vol. 24, No. 4, pp. 451-476
JEL classification: D24, E22, L32, L33

Download BibTex file | 

Many comparisons of public and private firms use a public/private ownership dummy variable to capture cost differences. If, however, public and private firms use different production technologies, the dummy-variable approach is misspecified. Data from public and private firms should not be pooled. Secondly, selectivity bias may arise, making it more difficult to identify cost differentials that actually exist. Thirdly, if data should be pooled, the resulting empirical model may be logically inconsistent. This paper compares public and private firms using the refuse collection costs of 170 firms in 115 Swedish municipalities. First, public production costs were 6 per cent lower than private production costs. Secondly, cost differences did not affect producer choice. It is crucial to adjust for selectivity. Data for private and public firms should not be pooled. The dummy-variable model is misspecified.

Full version (external link)

Search

Title (or part of title)
Author surname (or part of surname)